Common Reasons Car Insurance Claim Gets Rejected

It is an unpleasant sound that no one desires to hear. The crunch of metal. The hiss of steam. Your heart stands a-thumping in your chest. There is one consoling thought that comes after the first shock. “It’s okay. I have insurance.” It is precisely at this moment that you are paying your premiums on a monthly basis. You file your claim. You wait. Then, the email arrives. “We regret to inform you…” Your claim is denied. This is where a car insurance claim gets rejected. It is also more frequent than you believe.

This feeling is terrible. You feel betrayed. You feel angry. How can this happen? You paid for this coverage. The fact of the matter is that an insurance policy is a legal contract. It has rules. It also includes deadlines. The policy has extremely narrowed downsides. Just one little detail can make the company reject you.

That is what we are going to prevent. This guide is your shield. We shall discuss all the typical causes of a car insurance claim getting rejected. We will show you what to do next. Finally, we are going to make you see the small print. You will know how to put up an iron-clad claim. Your insurance is a promise. Let’s make sure they keep it.

Compare the Group Health Insurance vs Individual Policy — Key Differences to find what suits you best. Also, learn How Pre-Existing Diseases Affect Health Insurance Premiums and explore Understanding No-Claim Bonus in Health Insurance to maximize your savings.

Understanding the Car Insurance Claim Process

To draw up the curtain, first of all. So what comes of the process of filing a claim? You do it because you will be able to know what to do to prevent errors. It is an instruction manual on how to get your money.

What Happens Immediately After an Accident?

This is where you have a golden hour on your claim. Concerns with safety come first. And you may get out of a saving place. Check for injuries. Call 911 or the local police. This is not just a safety step. It is a critical claim step. Evidence giving credence to a police report is strong. It establishes a formal report of the event.

Filing Your Claim: The First Official Step

You must notify your insurer. Do this as soon as possible. Nevertheless, 24/7 claim hotlines are found with most companies. They also have mobile apps. The initial call is called the First Notice of Loss (FNOL). You will give fundamental insurance policy details. You will give an account of what has taken place. Be honest. Be clear. Do not guess or speculate.

The Role of the Insurance Adjuster

On filing, your case is given. It is given to an insurance adjuster (or claims adjuster). This individual is a professional investigator. It is their work to determine the damage. They ascertain whoever is in the wrong. Your story will be verified by them. They are neither your friend nor your enemy, but a company employee. Their aim is resolving the claim as per the policy.

Investigation and Assessment

The claim investigation is initiated by the adjuster. They will look at your car. They can request photographs that you have taken. Additionally, they will peruse through a police report. These will be called over to the other driver. They can also interrogate any witnesses. That is why it is crucial to receive information of witnesses. All these facts are taken by the adjuster.

The Final Decision: Approved, Partially Approved, or Rejected

The adjuster provides a recommendation. They check your coverage of policies. Is it within your policy to cover this kind of event? Were you out of car insurance deductible? Were all rules followed? They then decide. You can be approved in your claim. It can be partly approved (they can finance some of them, not all). Or, it can be neglected altogether.

“You should read your policy when you need it not after the accident.” – Insurance Proverb

The Big “Why”: Top Reasons Your Car Insurance Claim Gets Rejected

Now we get to the core issue. The reason behind a rejected car insurance claim gets rejected? It is almost never a surprise. The explanation is normally confined in details. Let us take a look at the most prevalent triggers of rejection.

Reason 1: You Missed the Filing Deadline (Lapse in Time)

Your policy has a time limit. You cannot have 6 months of waiting to claim. Majority of policies are rather vague. It is said that you have to report promptly or in a reasonable time. This protects them.

Why Do Deadlines Exist?

The insurers have to investigate at a fast pace. Evidence disappears. Witnesses forget details. Cars get repaired. Their claim investigation is significantly more difficult because of a long delay. It can even look suspicious. They might suspect that you have something to conceal. This time serves as justification to deny them.

What is a “Reasonable” Timeframe?

This is dependent on the state and company. A good rule is 24 to 72 hours. It is best to make the initial call at the location. Report the accident even without all the information. You can add details later. Timely claim filing is always important. Waiting a week is risky. It takes a month, in most cases, to kill your claim.

Reason 2: Providing Inaccurate or Incomplete Information

And this, is a cheap, yet an expensive, error. You should tell the truth when you are filing. You also must be complete. Even white lies and omissions can drown you.

Small Mistakes, Big Consequences

Perhaps you have the wrong name of the street. Perhaps you had wrongly told the time by one hour. These seem small. To an adjuster, however, they are red flags. When you do not fit the description of the police report, they become suspicious. They may suspect that you are committing insurance fraud.

Forgetting “Minor” Details

You should offer complete and accurate incident report. Did you have passengers? Say so. Were you running an errand? Say so. When you happen to forget something very important and later, it leaks out, then your credibility is lost. Misrepresentation can be used to reject the claim by the insurer. Never exaggerate and always remain factual. There is no problem in saying I do not remember or I do not know. This is superior to getting the wrong.

Reason 3: The “Policy Lapse” Nightmare

It is among the most agonizing causes. You had an accident. You get to know that you were canceled in your policy yesterday. This is a policy lapse. It is an indication that you were not covered at the time of the accident.

What is a Policy Lapse?

Any period without the active insurance is called a lapse. This normally occurs due to default. You missed a premium payment. The company sent you notices. You ignored them. Your policy was canceled. You are not covered as long as your accident occur one minute after the cancellation.

The Grace Period Myth

Most individuals subscribe to a grace period. This is a dangerous myth. Others have one, yet far too many do not. Or, grace period can be conditional. Do not assume you have one. Pay your premium on time. Every single time. Set up auto-pay. A policy lapse refers to a claim rejection that is guaranteed at 100%. It is completely avoidable.

Reason 4: The Driver Wasn’t Listed on Your Policy

Who was driving your car? This question is critical. Your policy covers you. Listed drivers also come under it. These are individuals in your household whom you added on the policy.

Permissive Use vs. Unlisted Drivers

The use of most policies is permissive. This includes a friend who takes your car on one occasion. But this has limits. Suppose it is loaned out by your roommate? They live with you. They must be on your policy. In case of any crash the claim will be denied. They are an unlisted driver coverage risk.

The “Excluded Driver” Trap

There are occasions when you leave out a driver. You do this to save money. Perhaps your teenage son has low driving statistics. You promise the insurer to omit him. This translates to reduced premium. However, this also implies that he does not have any coverage. What he gets away with is stealing your car one once only to crash, the case is dismissed. You specifically told the company not to cover him.

Reason 5: Driving Under the Influence (DUI)

This one is simple. It is also tragic. In case you cause an accident when intoxicated and high by the law, your claim is invalidated. Criminal acts are not insurable. A DUI is a serious crime.

An Automatic Denial

The other party damages will be paid by the insurer. The following is your liability insurance. They must do this by law. But they will not buy your automobile. Your collisional insurance is waived. They are not going to be covering your medical costs. As far as your own losses are concerned, you are fully on your own.

Know more about Understanding Riders in Life Insurance Plans and explore the Top 10 Health Insurance Plans for Families in 2025 for the best coverage. You can also read How to Calculate the Right Life Insurance Coverage for Your Family to make smart protection choices.

How Insurers Verify This

They will be awaiting the police report. If it writes a DUI test, they’ll know. If you are arrested or charged they will know. There is no hiding this. A DUI rejection is absolute. Once they pay the liability claim, they will most likely cancel your policy. Your future rates will be very high.

Reason 6: The Damage Doesn’t Meet Your Deductible

Sometimes, a claim is not “rejected.” It is just not “covered.” This may include your deductible, as often as possible. This is a place where there is often a misunderstanding.

Understanding Your Car Insurance Deductible

A deductible is what you have to pay for your share of the cost. You agree to pay this first as a certain amount. Let’s say your car insurance deductible is $1,000. You have an accident. The repair cost is $800. You file a claim. The insurer will “reject” it. Why? Because the damage ($800) is less than what the deductible ($1,000) is. You are responsible for the total amount of $800. (Internal Link: See our full guide: Choosing the Right Deductible)

When Filing Isn’t Worth It

But, always ask for a repair estimate services first. In the example at the start of this article, if the damage is $1,100; and your deductible is $1,000, is that worth filing? You’d only receive 100 dollars from the insurance company. But at renewal your premium is likely to increase. In many cases it is smarter to pay for the small repairs yourself. Use your insurance for major and putative costly, damage.

Reason 7: You Used Your Car for Business (Without Coverage)

This is a huge modern problem. Your personal auto coverage is for personal use. This means commuting to work. It means making a drive to the grocery store. It also means road trips. However, it does not mean using your car to earn some money.

Personal vs. Commercial Auto Insurance

If you are using your car for work you need commercial auto insurance. This includes delivering pizzas. It includes a catering business. This includes being a contractor going to job sites. If you were doing these when you crash then your personal policy will deny the claim.

The Rise of the “Gig Economy”

What about ridesharing – Uber, Lyft? Climate conundrums: What about food delivery (DoorDash, Uber Eats)? This is a gray area. These companies offer some insurances. But it is often limited. This may only pertain with having a passenger on. Your personal policy will not cover you while you are using the app. For that you need a special “rideshare” add-on. But without it you are driving with no coverage. (Internal Link: Read our guide on commercial auto insurance)

Reason 8: Lack of Sufficient Evidence

An insurance claim is a “she said, he said” battle. The one who is bringing more evidence wins. If your argument has no evidence, your argument is not strong. The insurer may deny it. They will say you have failed to prove your case.

The Power of Photos and Videos

Your phone is your best tool. Take photos of everything. Get all angles of all cars. Also, get the license plates. Be sure to capture the street signs. Document the skid marks. Finally, record the weather conditions. Take a video. Walk around the entire scene. You certainly can’t have too much evidence.

Why You Always Need a Police Report

We said this before. It is worth repeating. A police report is a third party, objective report. It includes information on drivers. Insurance information is also included. It often features a diagram. It may even assign preliminary fault. Without this report it is just your word against the other driver. Always call the police.

Table 1: Your At-the-Scene Evidence Checklist

Evidence Type	Why You Need It	Pro-Tip
Photos & Video	Shows undisputed damage and scene context.	Get close-ups and wide shots. Film a 360-degree walk-around.
Police Report	Official, third-party record of the incident.	Get the report number and officer’s name before you leave.
Witness Info	Backs up your story against the other driver.	Get their name and phone number. Ask them to text you “I was a witness.”
Other Driver’s Info	Needed to file the claim (name, license, insurance).	Take a photo of their insurance card and driver’s license.

Reason 9: You Admitted Fault at the Scene

An accident is emotional. Your first inclination is to be polite. But you may say “I’m so sorry, I didn’t see you.” This is a huge mistake. It is an admission of guilt.

Why “I’m Sorry” Can Cost You

The other driver’s insurer can do this against you. Your own insurer can use it. Admitting fault can make you liable in a court. This can cause your claim to discredited. It can also result in you being sued.

“At an accident scene, what you should do is that if you have only statements to make, you should only do them to the police. The rest, let your insurance take care of it.” – Legal Analyst

Let the Adjusters Do Their Job

You are not an expert. You might not necessarily know the precise laws of traffic. Maybe the other driver was driving too fast. The people could say: Later, I think his brake light was out. Never admit fault. Exchange information. Be polite. But be firm. Say, “We should allow our insurance companies to take up this.”

Reason 10: Non-Cooperation with the Insurer

Your policy is a contract. You have a “duty to cooperate.” This means that you need to assist the insurer with their investigation. If you don’t acknowledge them, they will be able to deny your claim.

What Does “Cooperation” Mean?

It means having to answer their calls. You should present requested documents. If asked, you must give a minute record statement. You need to let them check your car. Hiding your car is not allowed. You cannot refuse to talk.

Ignoring Calls and Requests

Why would someone do this? Maybe they are scared. Maybe they are busy. It does not matter. If the adjuster cannot reach you, then he cannot process your claim. After sometime, they will close the file. They will send a denial letter for non-cooperation. You must involved in the insurance claim process.

Reason 11: Policy Exclusions (The Fine Print)

This is the most complicated reason. Every policy does have an “Exclusions” section. This is a list of items the policy will not cover. A car insurance claim gets rejected simply because the event is on this list.

Common Exclusions: Wear and Tear

Insurance provides cover for sudden accident damage. It will not cover your car getting old. If your tire adds from the point that it’s old will blow out I’m not covered. If your engine is gone into failed high mileage that is not covered. This is “wear and tear,” and it’s your job.

Common Exclusions: Intentional Acts

And you can’t make your car crash on purpose. This is insurance fraud. If you injure your vehicle on purpose to collect money, the claim will not accepted. You will also likely be facing criminal charges. This also includes things like road rage. If you intentionally rammed into another car you are not covered.

Common Exclusions: Racing or Off-Road Use

Normal use on the roads is covered by your personal policy. It does not cover racing. High performance driving events are not included. Furthermore, it does not cover “mudding” or more serious off-roading. If you damage your car during these sorts of activities, the claim will be denied.

Be Proactive: How to Ensure Your Claim Gets Approved

You can avoid most of these problems. You just need to be proactive. A smooth claim starts before you even have an accident.

Before You Even Drive: Know Your Policy

The knowledge that you best carry is to be your weapons. You have to read your policy documents. Yes, they are boring. They are also essential. You have to know your coverage. What is your deductible? Who is on your policy? What are your exclusions?

Read the Policy Documents

Your company provides you with a “Declarations Page.” This is a summary. Read it. It teaches you what your limits for coverage are. It lists your drivers. Your vehicles are also listed on it. If something is wrong then call your agent right away. Get a full guide on How to Read Your Insurance Policy from Investopedia.

Update Your Policy Regularly

Life changes. Your policy has to change with it. Did you get a new car? Tell your insurer. Did your teenager receive their license? Tell your insurer. Did you move? Tell your insurer. Did you do a side-hustle of delivering food? Tell your insurer. Hiding these facts to save the money is not smart. It is a sure fire way to get a car insurance claim gets rejected.

At the Scene of the Accident: Your Action Plan

We have covered this. But it needs a clear plan. Your actions on the website of occurrence set the way for your whole declare. (Internal Link: Refresh with our full guide: What to Do After an Accident)

The “Do Nots”

• Do not leave the scene.
• Do not admit fault.
• Do not say “I’m sorry.”
• Do not get in an argument with the other driver.
• Do not agree to “settle it without insurance.”

The “Must Dos”

• Must call the police.
• Must check for injuries.
• Must take hundreds of photos.
• Must get witness information.
• Must exchange insurance and contact info.
• Must call your insurance company (FNOL).

During the Filing Process: Honesty and Speed

Once the claim is made, the perfect client. You want to be easy to work with. This makes the life of the adjuster easier. It makes your approbation come faster.

Report the Claim Immediately

We’ve said it before. Do not wait. Timely claim filing is key. The quicker your report the quicker you get paid. Just the likely, the more quickly you report, the less suspicious you appear.

Be 100% Truthful

Do not lie. Do not exaggerate. Avoid “forgetting” details. The adjuster will find out. They have databases. They have investigation tools. Just one lie would destroy your entire claim. It can even result in getting prosecuted on insurance fraud. Stick to the facts. Be clear. Be cooperative.

Table: Claim Rejection Prevention Plan

Action Step	When to Do It	Prevents This Rejection
Pay Your Premium	On time, every time. (Use auto-pay)	Policy Lapse
Read Your Policy	Today. And at every renewal.	Policy Exclusions
Update Your Policy	Any time you move, add a driver, or change car use.	Unlisted Driver / Business Use
Call Police at Scene	Immediately after an accident.	Lack of Evidence
Take Photos	At the scene, before moving cars (if safe).	Lack of Evidence / Fault Disputes
Do NOT Admit Fault	At the scene, when talking to anyone.	Admitted Fault
Report Claim ASAP	Within 24 hours of the accident.	Missed Filing Deadline

Fighting Back: Your Claim Was Rejected. Now What?

Let’s say that you did everything right. Or maybe you did a little something wrong. And your claim was still rejected. Do not give up. You have the right to appeal. A rejection is not the end of the road.

“A rejected claim isn’t the end. It’s the start of your appeal.” – Claims Advocate

Step 1: Understand the Exact Reason

The rejection must be put in writing. The company must give you a formal claim denial letter. This letter must describe the specific reason for the denial. It must also cite the exact portion of your policy that they are referring to in order to justify the same. Vague answers on the phone are not good enough.

Step 2: Review Your Policy Again

Now you have the letter. Open your policy documents. Find the section they quoted. Read it carefully. Do you take it in another way? Does it actually apply to the situation you are in? Look for ambiguity. Look for conflict language in other sections of the policies.

Step 3: Gather Your Evidence

Create a “rebuttal file.” This file should include:

• The original police report.
• Photographs and videos of the scene that you take.
• Any repair estimates you got.
• Witness statements.
• A timeline for all of your calls and interactions.

You are building a case. You are demonstrating that they were incorrect in rejecting them.

Step 4: File an Internal Appeal

Your first step is to make an appeal within the company. Call the adjuster. Tell them you disagree. Ask to speak to their manager. There is an example of a formal letter or email. Attach your evidence. Explicitly explain why their rejection is false. Be polite. Be professional. But be firm. Many claims are overturned at this stage.

Step 5: Escalate the Issue

What if the manager agrees to the adjuster? You are still not done. It is possible to escalate it further. You have two powerful options left with you.

Contact Your State’s Department of Insurance

Every state has a governing body. They regulate insurance companies. You can make a formal complaint to them. This is free. They will be investigating your case. With these guys they will make contact with the insurer on your behalf. This creates a substantial amount of pressure on the company. Find your State Insurance Commissioner via USA.gov.

When to Hire an Attorney

If the claim is large, you should contact a lawyer by phone. Look for an attorney that specializes in “bad faith” insurance claims. Most of them offer a complimentary consultation. These people will be able to tell you if you’ve got a strong case or not. They know the law. They know the tricks that insurers play. This is your ultimate weapon. You can find a lawyer through the American Bar Association).

Your Final Checkpoint for a Smooth Claim

A car insurance claim gets rejected because of many reasons. But most of them can be avoided. It all comes down to two things. Knowledge and Preparation. Know your policy. Prepare for the worst.

You now have that knowledge. The process is understood by you. You know the red flags. There is a plan of what to do at the scene. You know how to fight back. Insurance is a complex world. But you are a much-informed customer now. You pay for that policy. And you deserve its protection it promises.

Find out Term Insurance vs Whole Life Insurance — Which One Suits You Best? and Why Millennials Should Consider Life Insurance Early. Don’t miss the Best Life Insurance Companies with High Claim Settlement Ratio 2025 and learn How to File a Car Insurance Claim Step-by-Step for smooth claim handling.

Frequently Asked Questions